Chasing The Unicorn

Your Quest For the Perfect Pour
The seal of The Wantage — a wantage rod standing in the bung of a barrel

Issue

The Wantage

Week of 3–7 August 2026

The gap between what the barrel claims and what is in it.

← The Wantage  /  Week of 3–7 August 2026

01

The Question

one question, argued

Is American whiskey shrinking or growing right now?

02

The Verdict

The positionBoth, and that's the problem. Production is being cut everywhere you look, bulk demand is falling off a cliff, and the same bottles that traded on the secondary market a month ago are selling for less today. Meanwhile the brands are still pouring concrete for new rickhouses and raising prices as if none of that were happening. Somebody's math is wrong, and this week's distributor bankruptcy is the first bill coming due.

-4.7 pts (41.3% -> 36.6%)
The same tracked bottles' resale premium over MSRP fell almost five points in one month, and it fell faster than the month before that — the demand signal underneath every rickhouse groundbreaking this week is already going the wrong way.
03

The Evidence

8 points · 2026-05-06 to 2026-07-27 to 2026-06-09

Assembled from the daily brief’s own archive across months — the part no single day’s news can show. Every line is dated so it can be checked.

2026-05-06MGP's contract price for bulk new-distillate whiskey dropped-12% YoY, to $14.82 per proof-gallon
2026-06-07Kentucky distillers as a group made less whiskey than a year earlier-12.7% YoY proof-gallons, Q2 census
2026-07-06Buyers ordering new whiskey from MGP under contract pulled back hard-19% YoY in Q2 order books
2026-07-13Heaven Hill broke ground on a brand new rickhouse campus while cutting its own new-make output 15% the same month42,000-barrel capacity, 18-month build
2026-07-15Heaven Hill told distributors wholesale prices are going up across its core lineup+4-6%
2026-07-22Heaven Hill raised wholesale prices again, this time on Elijah Craig and Larceny specifically+6-8%, effective Aug 1
2026-07-27Wilderness Trail bought a second rickhouse site even as its Bardstown counterparts were cutting production~18,000 barrels, Boyle County
2026-07-27 to 2026-06-09The same bottles tracked month over month on secondary sold for a smaller premium over MSRP in July than in June, and the drop is accelerating41.3% -> 36.6% (-4.7 pts, n=18), after a smaller -1.0 pt drop the month before
04

So What

by where you sit

The same week means different things to a distiller, a retailer and a collector.

If you make whiskeyDon't read the capacity cuts as proof that scarcity will bail out your pricing in three years — lock in what contract volume you can now, because the bulk market is telling you the buyers already priced in the shortage and walked away.
If you build or launch a brandStop assuming a wholesale price increase will stick just because Heaven Hill's did — check whether your bottle actually trades above MSRP on secondary before you raise, because the matched-basket floor just fell for the second straight month.
If you distributeTreat this week's bankruptcy as a preview, not a one-off — audit which of your suppliers are still expanding capacity while cutting current-year output, because that mismatch is exactly what breaks a distributor's working capital.
If you buy for retailDon't over-order allocated bottles banking on flip value — the resale premium on bottles you already stock is shrinking, not growing, and it's shrinking faster each month.
05

The Call

dated and falsifiable

Three predictions with dates on them, published so they can be wrong.

By 30 Nov 2026MGP reports another quarter of YoY bulk-whiskey revenue decline in double digits when it files Q3 earnings.

By 31 Dec 2026The matched-basket secondary floor for the same tracked bottles falls below 33%, extending the June-July drop for a third straight reading.

By 31 Dec 2026At least one more national or regional spirits distributor files for bankruptcy or is acquired under distress.

Calls are never edited after publication. When one misses it is marked in corrections and stays on this page.

06

What I’m Watching

the publisher’s own read

What I'm watching is the resale premium, because it's the number that tells you whether this is a correction or a crash. It's dropped from 41.3% to 36.6% in a month — call that the buyer's report card on what distillers are charging. If that number keeps sliding another 4 or 5 points by the next Whisky Auctioneer close in September, the bankruptcy filed this week won't be the last one, and some of these brands are going to have to eat a price cut they haven't announced yet. If it flattens instead, I'll admit the buyer overreacted and the distillers timed this better than I gave them credit for.

— John Schuster II, publisher, the American Whiskey Industry Brief

How this is built

The Wantage takes one question the trade is actually arguing about and answers it with evidence assembled across months, not a recap of the week. Every figure comes from the American Whiskey Industry Brief’s own daily record, and the monthly measurements behind it are published in The Gauge. Where the archive disagrees with itself, the figure is withheld rather than asserted.

Open this issue (PDF) →

Cite as: The Wantage, Vol. 1 No. 17 (Week of 3–7 August 2026), Drunken Unicorn Productions.

The archive

August 20261 issue
July 20265 issues
June 20264 issues
May 20265 issues
April 20262 issues

← Week of 27–31 July 2026

Every issue of The Wantage, and this week’s →